Advertise mind mapping & related products & services on WikIT.  Click for details.

Hexagon maps


From WikIT
(Redirected from Influence maps)
Jump to: navigation, search

Hexagon maps were proposed as a tool for Systems Thinking by Anthony M Hodgson in a paper Hexagons for systems thinking (pdf 1992). It was described as "an approach to bridging the gap between the generalist thinking of decision makers and the specialism of modellers by concentrating on the preliminary issue conceptualisation stage of modelling."

Hexagon-map.png
Influence map.jpg
Issues, ideas and possible solutions are written onto magnetic hexagon shapes, and after the first round are clustered into "Issue maps". These maps are examined for additional ideas that the clustering may bring out, and lines are drawn to indicate influence between areas giving an Issue map like the one on the right.

The paper goes on to introduce the use of colors to encode styles of thinking into the diagram.


lateral thinking
 yellow 
opportunity spotting
critical thinking
black
innovation
imaginative thinking
green
innovation
judgemental thinking
brown
quality appraisal
holistic thinking
blue
environmental scanning
systems thinking
orange
designing
metacognition
white
thinking about thinking
chaotic thinking
grey
ambiguity
strategic thinking
purple
directing
decision thinking
red
action


This uses elements of de Bono's Six Thinking Hats, which it mentions in the paper, but extends that to categorize additional thinking styles. And whereas de Bono's technique assigns a duty to adopt a specified thinking style to each member of a team, the table of thinking categories above is used to classify thoughts represented by the hexagons after they have been collected.

Dave Snowden's organization Cognitive Edge has an article The Future, Backwards, that proposes a different approach and alternative uses of colors specific to that approach.

If you have seven colors, they suggest a separate color for each of: Current State (CS); Turning points backwards from CS; Heaven; Hell; Turning points backwards from heaven; Turning points backwards from hell; Accidents on hell or heaven pathway.
Of for a more restricted case: Current state (CS); Turning points backwards from CS, heaven and hell; Heaven & Hell (marked); Accidents.

But whichever method you use and colors you choose, having colors on the clustered hexagons provides a quick visual overview of the way thinking is trending as discussion proceeds.

In this article, we have picked out the visual elements, but the papers linked to above provide much more on alternative uses and benefits of this method.

Criticism

To regular users of maps with nodes and connecting lines (edges) the choice of a hexagon, with its limit of 6 neighbors, may seem to have its roots more in the convenience of topology than in any real-life consideration of how issues and ideas are connected.

Software

Software to produce these specialized maps was implemented by (at least) two software publishers, Idon Resources and Visual Concept, though neither website seems to have been updated recently. The Visual Concept link shows more examples of hexagon maps.

Acknowledgements

Thanks to John Fraser of Arum Systems Ltd for the pointer to this, and for providing the above real-life example.

Thanks to Pascal Venier for pointing out the Cognitive Edge article.

Support WikIT's work
with a $2.50 donation:
For free information about the hundreds of
visual thinking tools available, visit the

Visual Thinking Center
     'G+'